dial v for vendetta
Sep. 8th, 2006 04:03 pm.
I just finished watching the movie, having purchased it from Costco today. I think I'd have found it pretty satisfactory if I hadn't read the comics a score of times first. I had to keep divorcing my expectations from the book, but I kept going back to it, and finding it a little less sharp, a little less vivid. Ultimately, the screenwriters decided to substitute what they felt was an equivalent story, based perhaps on something else they saw or read.
Still, an impressive amount of the script came through. Like other Alan Moore graphic novels, I think it would have been better made as a miniseries. Failing that, I still think it could have been made at about the length they made it without going to a different story. Watching along, seeing what had been left out, it seems to me that they could have just kept leaving things out all the way to the end and still ended up in the same place. The substitute story is interesting in its own way, I think, and I don't dislike it.
If I have any beef with it, it's the "making of" that accompanies it. Here we are treated to all sorts of silly junk. They betray some ignorance of the comics field when they let the creators rhapsodize over how cinematic the comic is, as if this was an invention of the comic -- as if comics and movies haven't been feeding off of each other since Will Eisner decided to make his living from sequential art. I almost expected the featurette to be called "Biff! Bam! Pow! Comics Not Just For Children Any More!"
I hope I'm past the worst of it. I'm going to try and watch the rest of the supplementary material. Wish me luck, and I'll see you all right here. Same Bat-Time! Same Bat-Channel!
.
I just finished watching the movie, having purchased it from Costco today. I think I'd have found it pretty satisfactory if I hadn't read the comics a score of times first. I had to keep divorcing my expectations from the book, but I kept going back to it, and finding it a little less sharp, a little less vivid. Ultimately, the screenwriters decided to substitute what they felt was an equivalent story, based perhaps on something else they saw or read.
Still, an impressive amount of the script came through. Like other Alan Moore graphic novels, I think it would have been better made as a miniseries. Failing that, I still think it could have been made at about the length they made it without going to a different story. Watching along, seeing what had been left out, it seems to me that they could have just kept leaving things out all the way to the end and still ended up in the same place. The substitute story is interesting in its own way, I think, and I don't dislike it.
If I have any beef with it, it's the "making of" that accompanies it. Here we are treated to all sorts of silly junk. They betray some ignorance of the comics field when they let the creators rhapsodize over how cinematic the comic is, as if this was an invention of the comic -- as if comics and movies haven't been feeding off of each other since Will Eisner decided to make his living from sequential art. I almost expected the featurette to be called "Biff! Bam! Pow! Comics Not Just For Children Any More!"
I hope I'm past the worst of it. I'm going to try and watch the rest of the supplementary material. Wish me luck, and I'll see you all right here. Same Bat-Time! Same Bat-Channel!
.

